The 3 Best Online Trading Brokers


Navigating the world of online trading sites

As new traders, people are often faced with a plethora of choices when venturing out into the retail trading world. Whether you are looking for a trading room, a place for hot penny stock picks or just a basic stock market and trading education, you have got to do your research. Whatever you decide, without a good online trading broker, you are truly powerless to act upon anything in the markets. Long gone are the days of bucket shops and panicked phone calls to your broker.


Finding a top trading room

Secondary to a good broker is a top notch online trading room with great mentors and educators. The experience of trading the stock market can, and usually is a costly one. Much like higher education is for doctors, new traders find themselves bogged down in overhead and costly trading errors that eat into their precious capital.  The most important thing a new trader can do is make an investment in their education by studying the markets.  Keep in mind, 90% of traders WILL fail. That does not mean they have to. Trading online among a community of like-minded traders with varying skill sets can only serve to benefit the keen listener. Going it alone will always be harder when it’s you versus the institutions.


Qualities of the best online trading brokers:


Well Priced Broker Commissions

  • The most important option to most novice investors will likely be costs. As mentioned earlier, the overhead costs involved with trading prove to be insurmountable for many new traders with smaller capital. Costs from online trading brokers can come from commissions, ECN fees, data fees, margin fees and even fees for phone order executions. Believe it or not, these fees can and will affect your profit and loss.


Execution Speed and Software Stability

  • I also place high value on speed of execution and software stability. For what it’s worth, I will sacrifice bells and whistles ANY day just to have the ability to place a trade, get a FAST execution at MY price, and not have the software crash on me mid order. Believe it or not, that does happen and it has happened to me.


The Right Broker for your Trading Style

  • Amenities are nice. We like them in our hotel rooms, we like them when we are spending a lot of our money on cars and any time we feel that we should get a little bit extra value for the amount of money we are entrusting. Online trading brokers are no different. In a world where everyone is selling themselves as the best online broker service, what really matters is what is useful to you. Do you trade futures, forex, options, commodities, stocks, OTC and international markets? Are all of those options important to you in a broker? If not, then your search just got easier. Focus on the kind of trading you do and want to do. Don’t worry about excess. You can always open up accounts later on with more suitable online trading brokers.


Online Broker Customer Service

  • Customer service. This might seem like an obvious one, but let me tell you that some brokers are completely anti customer. I won’t name them here, but you will find that in this world, nobody cares about YOUR money more than YOU. Make it a priority to research and contact customer service departments at various brokers. See who responds to your inquiries and how long it takes them. Think about it this way, brokers know that most traders will blow up their accounts and be gone in a short time. Their purpose is to get their claws into as much of equity as possible, and if they ignore your issues long enough, you are statistically likely to be gone soon anyways. Find the brokers who make the effort to care about your concerns.


New Customer Incentives

  • Finally, for new traders, I would focus my consideration for the best online trading broker to a place that provides incentives. Not all online trading brokers offer incentives, but many do, especially for new traders. Whether you get free trading for a month or 100 free trades or no interest margin rates for a specified period of time, it all adds up to savings for a new trader. If you are jumping in to retail stock trading, then minimizing initial overhead costs via commissions or whatever you can will pay off in the end. Incentives can even come in the form of a free paper trading accounts offered with your intended broker. Don’t pass up the opportunity to test drive!


Top 3 Best Online Trading Brokers


Based on the above criteria we rank the following brokers as the Top 3 best online trading brokers for Day Traders.  Keep in mind, if you are looking for a broker for investing or swing trading, this line up may not match your needs.


Speedtrader is our choice for Best Online Trading Broker

Both Speedtrader and Suretrader are owned by StockUSA.  Speedtrader is a New York based broker that allows direct access routing to the stock market.  This means you choose which ECN (electronic communication network) you will use to communicate with the exchange.  Brokers that allow direct access routing are almost always faster than brokers that do not allow it.  Speedtrader also features advanced hotkey settings, dark pool routing and allows traders to collect ECN rebates.  Read our complete in depth Speedtrader Review here.


Suretrader is our 2nd choice for Best Online Trading Broker

Suretrader uses the exact same software but it located in the Bahamas.  By having their office in the Bahamas traders who use Suretrader are exempt from the PDT (pattern day trader) rules.  All of the benefits of Speedtrader are available at Suretrader.  This allows a trader with as little as $500 to day trade.  In the United States this would be unheard of.  Many of our students are trading with Suretrader because they are under the PDT level.  Click here to read our full review of Suretrader.


UPDATE: We have discovered that Guy Gentile, the founder of Suretrader was indicted for Penny Stock Manipulation.  At this time there are no indictments against Suretrader specifically, or anything to suggest Suretrader was involved in any wrong doing.  We will continue to follow this headline.  Read the SEC Press Release here.

This is the official response we got when we asked Suretrader about the filing.

” Your concern is understandable given the headlines but there is no cause for concern. In reference to the news reports concerning Mr. Gentile, I assure you that Swiss America Securities Ltd, is not complicit in any of the allegations brought against him. Those charges pre-date our existence and although Mr. Gentile is the founder, we thought it best that he step down as President earlier this year given the circumstances.

Swiss America Securities Ltd is licensed and regulated by the Securities Commission of the Bahamas and audited financial statements are prepared and submitted annually to the Securities Commission of the Bahamas by a leading and reputable accounting firm. We are exchange control regulated by the Central Bank of the Bahamas and maintain the required net capital to operate. We also hold Financial Institution Professional Liability Insurance through American Home Assurance Co. (AIG’s affiliate) and we are an IRS Qualified Intermediary and are FATCA compliant.

I wish to reiterate that SureTrader, a division of Swiss America Securities, Ltd is in no way culpable in these court actions against Mr. Gentile. We are now, and always have been, compliant with all regulatory requirements both locally in the Bahamas and in our international clients’ jurisdictions.

No charges have been brought against SureTrader and we continue to conduct business as usual.

I appreciate you reaching out for some clarification in this matter and feel free to contact me should you have any more questions or concerns. ”


Lightspeed Financial is our 3rd choice for Best Online Trading Broker

Lightspeed comes in as our second best online trading broker.  They allow direct access routing, dark pool routing, and competitive commissions.  The Lightspeed pro platform is excellent and allows for advanced use of hotkeys which are critical for day traders.  The commissions at Lightspeed are slightly more expensive than Speedtrader.


best online trading broker


In the end, it doesn’t matter what you decide, so long as you are comfortable with your decision and you feel like your hard earned money is safe. The best online trading broker might different for you than it is for me, but so long as both our needs are met, it’s a win win. And competition is healthy for the marketplace, so, don’t be afraid to try out multiple brokers before committing to any one.  It’s worth noting that brokers such as ETrade, TDAmeritrade, and Interactive Brokers are extremely popular among investors and swing traders but are typically not as popular among day traders due to slower execution speeds and less reliable software.



Reviews by Warrior Trading